Reviews by Muddy
Summary: Past Featured Story



Edward Cullen, former Confederate soldier, begins a journey from his home in Tennessee, to that of his only living relative in Texas. Along the way, he meets a girl. He's running from the past. She's running from a future she doesn't want. drabble-ish

Thanks very much to Cared for the beautiful banner!


Categories: Canon Pairings, Twilight, All Human
Characters: Bella/Edward
Genre: Historical, Romance
Language: English
TWCS Romance Contest: None
Series: Amberina's Completed Favs List, Stories Read by CNYBella, Lilyellacullens want to read list!
Chapters: 80 Table of Contents
Completed: Yes Word count: 75743 Read Count: 123073
[Report This] Published: 28 Apr 2012 Updated: 28 Feb 2013
Reviewer: Muddy Signed
Date: 03 Jul 2012 Title: Chapter 1: Chapter 1

don't review often, but had to tell you that I love your story, can't wait for the next chapters!



Author's Response: Thank you so much!

Summary:

Edward and Bella, kidnapped and forced to play out a sick man's fantasy where every decision has a consequence. Will Edward and Bella be able to admit their love after the trials they endure? ExB AxJ. Language,lemons, sexual violence,unconventional.

Thank you to JA Mash for the banner.


Categories: Canon Pairings, Twilight, All Human
Characters: Bella/Edward
Genre: Angst, Drama, Erotica, Romance, Suspense/Thriller
Language: English
TWCS Romance Contest: None
Series: Drive's Stories to read that are Completed, Lilyellacullens want to read list!, My Favorite Stories, Dumbi's Most Wanted
Chapters: 89 Table of Contents
Completed: No Word count: 453698 Read Count: 923138
[Report This] Published: 02 Jun 2012 Updated: 29 Sep 2015
Reviewer: Muddy Signed
Date: 22 Jul 2013 Title: Chapter 73: Chapter 63 (back to IR)

Loved the Elizabeth chapters just read them and this. Oh Edward! He's so frustrating at times! He can't bail on Bella and the babies that would be such a crappy result after everything they have been through. I hope they talk and sort it out they love one another!! So relieved they are finally off that island and getting medical attention.  They are all gonna need a whole lot of counselling on top of that I'd reckon!! I don't know why but I have a bad feeling about the future of Tanya. I am also hoping that as well as Edward and Bella sorting out their heads together that the situation about them and Emmett and Rose comes out and is all ok quickly. I think it time everyone started spilling their guts tbh! lol

Reviewer: Muddy Signed
Date: 04 Feb 2013 Title: Involuntary Rapture

as per my review for chapter 49 - Noooooooo!!! Don't listen to people that have complaints about your story, if they don't like it they should just not read it and leave it for the people that are enjoying it (and absolutely effin lovin it - i.e me!!) Please don't pull this story it would be really sad for you and for those of us that wait on our hands for your next chapter :-)



Author's Response:

I won't pull it, and I will finish it, but I can't write it as it happened because it violates some rules. I will do the best I can.

Reviewer: Muddy Signed
Date: 30 Apr 2013 Title: Chapter 57: Chapter 57

Another good chapter! OMG I can't believe Tanya talk about foot in mouth in more than one way! She knows how Bella and Edward feel about each other then starts talking to Bella about how much Edward loves blow jobs like she is going to want to think about Tanya doing that with him!! That came across as so insensitive. Ok good now she's pregnant so that gives them more space to breathe doesn't it? Or will James now demand he be allowed to fuck Bella? Now they have to plan how they are getting off that bloody island I don't even want to think about what will happen to the baby if its born there :-(  I have very violent thoughts about what I would do to those men before I left that island. Thing is you don't know how you would react in an extremely stressful and strange situation but while I am comfortable and safe in my home typing this I am thinking there would be a lot of blood and appendages hanging by a thread at my hands and slow painful deaths!! loL!! You said I could pm you to get a spoiler on the conception date and I would love to pm you Noc but that function is disabled on here - something about abused facility which is sad for the people that wouldn't abuse it. So how can I do that?



Author's Response:

You search nocturnalemi@gmail.com on facebook. Or you search Nocturnal Emissions Wreck Room.... then u message me, and I message u.  And thanks sooo much for the chapter.



Author's Response:

You search nocturnalemi@gmail.com on facebook. Or you search Nocturnal Emissions Wreck Room.... then u message me, and I message u.  And thanks sooo much for the review!

Reviewer: Muddy Signed
Date: 24 Mar 2013 Title: Chapter 53: Chapter 53

I'm glad they cleared up their misunderstanding of their reactions, but it makes me wonder more and more about if they do get off that island will they trust in the feelings the other has for them or doubt it and think it they only felt that way because of the situation they were in together. I would be so interested to see the aftermath of all this and was happens as a result in the real world for them especially if she has become pregnant now and gives birth to their baby. Don't know if you plan to cover any of that but its a question that keeps popping up in my head at the mo as it feels to me like we are nearing some kind of end now.



Author's Response:

we are nearing an end to the time on the island, but there will be quite a bit of time left in the story. They have terrible difficulty after they leave the island. I don't want to go into specifics, but I will if you pm me. I am a hea girl though

Reviewer: Muddy Signed
Date: 27 Aug 2013 Title: Chapter 76: Chapter 66

Its seems its all going quite well so far for them considering what they have been through. It's nice to read. I'm sad and pissed for Bella and I started off feeling a little of understanding for Edward and how he felt unsure of how things would be in the real world but he just assumes too much and acts on it. Doesn't stop to ask and communicate. He just comes across as a coward to me now and someone that is running away and using some shit he knows nothing about as an excuse.  I hope Bella makes him work hard to earn her trust again as she is going to think he will just run off at the first hurdle again. 



Author's Response:

He just can't admit how crushed he is at losing his child.

Reviewer: Muddy Signed
Date: 14 Jun 2013 Title: Chapter 60: Chapter 60

to anyone reading this review contains a disturbing real life story so don't read if you don't want to know about it.

 

Oh poor Bree. I am really going to say something that some be a little controversial but if I were Bree and in those circumstances I really don't know if I would be happy to bring the baby into the world given that situation and place she has arrived in, I guess she must have blind hope that the good people there like Alice etc will get her baby out of there and keep her safe. But there is also a fair chance that her daughter could grow up in that life and I am not sure I would want her to face that. It reminds me of a terrible story I once read years ago about an apparantly beatiful little girl that was killed by her own devastated family who felt it was the only way to protect her because of the fact that they were refugees and were being descended on by a very large terrible group of men that had no qualms about raping women and children repeatedly and murdering them after. This happened in a desert and they suffocated her and buried her there before the group reached them. I think I read it in a broad sheet newspaper here in the UK years ago and remember being so upset by it.  On that note I really hope Bella gets out of there before she is too big too and that they never find her, Edward or their children. I need a happy ending after all this!! :-(



Author's Response:

You will get your happy ending. I'm not sure if you read the other to stories that go with this one, but if you remember, Aro's mother took her own life and the life of her daughter to save her from the torture. I also assure you that there will be a happy ending, and thought it might not be "happy" and "perfect" soon, there will be a major plot development in the next few chapters. Bree's death is having a huge impact on them all.

Reviewer: Muddy Signed
Date: 18 Mar 2013 Title: Chapter 52: Chapter 52

I am glad the consummation ceremony didn't feel dragged out when reading it I felt sick for Bella and Edward about that part. Poor Edward, he doesn't realise that all Bella needs is his reassurance and comfort.



Author's Response:

Im glad you liked it!

Reviewer: Muddy Signed
Date: 25 Apr 2013 Title: Chapter 56: Chapter 56

Second attempt at submitting my review so sorry if this has come through twice. Good chapter! Got me thinking that it's good that Bella and Edward are still able to separate everything that happens to them there to their own personal intimate relationship with each other. I would imagine in reality most people would shut down sexually, or maybe it would heighten your urges because you crave a more normal (to them) experience so they don't forget how sex should feel to them, I dunno.  My paranoid mind was praying that James wasn't injecting his own fluids into Bella to try and get her pregnant with his baby instead of Edward's as some sort of revenge. I really hope not and that it was Edward's swimmers!! :-/ I am glad the breast feeding/conception thing was mentioned as I rememeber being told after having my two babies not to rely on breastfeeding as birth control as it just isn't reliable, but I had heard it made it harder to conceive as it can stop ovulation.  Anyway, starting to get anxious for them to find out she's pregnant so she's out of danger and can hopefully think about escaping that place.



Author's Response:

Thanks for the super review! I'm not so sure James isn't injecting his own swimmers, and he has thought of it. But here is why he wouldn't. If he were to get Bella pregnant, it would piss Aro off to no end. And it would do him little good. He is much better to let Bella carry Aro heir, make sure it is born a boy, then kill Edward in an "accident" and take Bella and the child as his own and wait for Aro to pass. PM me for a spoiler as to the date of conception.

Reviewer: Muddy Signed
Date: 02 Jan 2013 Title: Chapter 47: Chapter 47

I have been reading this for a while but this is my first review (shame faced admission) this has me gripped, its so twisted and messed up that its compulsive viewing, its so disturbing that you just have to know what happens next!

 

There weren’t words to describe how I felt at that moment, joined as one, knowing that he’d done something with me that he’d never done with anyone else, and that at this exact moment, we could be creating life from our love.

I am happy for Bella that her first time was a good experience esp in the circumstances but after reading this sentence which reminds you that they are in love with one another and would likely love a baby they make together I can't imagine the stress they will feel if she does become pregnant in that place, I am really hoping they escape before their baby is born if they make one :-/

Reviewer: Muddy Signed
Date: 30 Jan 2013 Title: Chapter 49: Chapter 49

Nooooo!! What the hell is he doing to her? I hope she's hallucinating or dreaming.  Please don't leave it so long for the next update I don't think I can handle the wait! On another note Edward crying and telling Bella to do as she was told was heartbreaking he clearly loves her and comes across as feeling responsible for everything thats happening to them but makes me wonder if he had some idea of what would be happening to her that night?

Reviewer: Muddy Signed
Date: 05 Apr 2013 Title: Chapter 54: Chapter 54

Abuse breeds abuse I guess. Doesn't make me feel any sympathy for him. Physically he is dishing out the same and sometimes worse than he has suffered imo.
I guess the difference is he loved his abuser. Still no excuse.

I won't pm you Noc re my thoughts about whats in the real world for Edward and Bella because I have been reading this for months and months and been enjoying
it as its been updated. I will carry on being patient and read it as you post it rather than you give me any idea of what they will face. I can't wait to
see how it all unfolds and ends! It's such an addictive story!

Reviewer: Muddy Signed
Date: 04 Jun 2013 Title: Chapter 59: Chapter 59

Glad Jasper is helping Bree out in the only way he can. Poor girl seems so terrified for her baby :(  And finally we know for sure that Alice is Edward's sister and he knows now. I wonder what Alice's reaction to that will be. Is it me or are Edward and Bella becoming a little distant with each other since they have found out about her pregnany or does it just seem that way as the chapters haven't focused on them so intensley? 



Author's Response:

You know, I never thought of it, but they haven't become distant, but different. They are more comfortable with each other. They are like a true married couple. Some things are becomming routine. There is a lot going on right now, and I couldn't keep just focusing on their sex. And Bella's torture, though terrible to be kept captive, is really not happening right now. Thanks so much for your review and making me think!

Reviewer: Muddy Signed
Date: 11 Sep 2013 Title: Chapter 77: Chapter 67

I have loved this story to but I have to agree entirely with jess641 I think there needs to be more about what is going on with Edward and Bella as the story was mostly focused on them before they escaped. I am also frustrated and angry at both Edward and Bella for the way they are both behaving. Edward needs to pull his head out of his ass and start acting with his brain and not his ego and Bella needs to toughen up and not let Edward abandon her the way he has based on his assumptions!! Because of this I didn't feel happy for Alice and Jasper as I probably would have if something more pro active was happening between E&B as I am so frustrated about them!! And although Tanya has suffered and moved over to the side of E&B and A&J I can't believe E&B forgave her so easily for getting them to that island in the first place. Still I am sticking with this to the end its been one amazing ride but I am just frustrated with it at the moment but patience was never my strength.

Walk by mustlovertp Rated: NC-17 starstarstarstarstar [Reviews - 259]
Summary: Past Featured Story

stories/38123/images/Walk_banner.jpg 

 

 

After a betrayal leaves Edward reeling, he decides to change the course of his life. Starting over can be a daunting task. Will he let a certain brown eyed beauty help him find what he's looking for?

Rated NC-17 for adult situations and language           *Banner by Falling Stars*


Categories: Canon Pairings, Twilight
Characters: Bella/Edward
Genre: Romance
Language: English
TWCS Romance Contest: None
Series: Drive's Stories to read that are Completed and Not completed, My favs past present and future , Read & Enjoyed
Chapters: 20 Table of Contents
Completed: Yes Word count: 110402 Read Count: 49588
[Report This] Published: 15 Jun 2012 Updated: 28 Mar 2013
Reviewer: Muddy Signed
Date: 18 Sep 2012 Title: Chapter 13: Chapter 13

Oh no poor Bella! I hope you post the next chapter soon, I can't hold my breath for long! Lets hope Edward busts in and kicks his arse seriously hard. I love this story, so well written. I am now checking out your other stories too. :)



Author's Response:

Thank you. It's really nice to receive such compliments! I'm happy you're enjoying the story. I'll be updating later today!  Thanks again  xoxox

Reviewer: Muddy Signed
Date: 19 Sep 2012 Title: Chapter 14: Chapter 14

Yay, glad Edward kicked Laurent's ass and Bella is ok!  Aww, I wondered if a baby was on the way when she was feeling faint when she stood up in the bath. So pleased for Edward as Bella will happily have his baby, not like that evil Kate.Can't wait for more - love this story :)

I have just read your Across the Hall story since I typed my last review (pretty fast reader) - thats a great story too! Great writing!



Author's Response:

I'm really glad you liked the chapter! Thanks for reading (ATH, too!)  xoxox

Reviewer: Muddy Signed
Date: 04 Oct 2012 Title: Chapter 15: Chapter 15

Aw loved it! Having a rubbish week, so was happy to see this update today and with such a great chapter :) So sweet.



Author's Response:

That was nice-thank you. I'm glad that I could help brighten your week just a little :) xoxox

Wild Child by FluffyLiz Rated: NC-17 starstarstarstarstar [Reviews - 756]
Summary: Past Featured Story

stories/6405/images/WildChild(TWCS).jpg

Just months away from inheriting a fortune and the family business, 17 year old orphan, Bella,  is out of control – a wild child with a platinum card and a killer bod.  Can Edward, as her legal guardian and CEO of Swan Publishing, rein her in and prevent her from ruining everything he’s worked for?  AH.  Rated M for a reason.


Categories: Twilight, Canon Pairings, All Human
Characters: Bella/Edward
Genre: Angst, Drama, Romance
Language: English
TWCS Romance Contest: None
Series: Drive's Stories to read that are Completed, G8or Favor8s Read, Lady Luciole's Favorites TwiHu, Stories I've Already read, Lilyellacullens want to read list!
Chapters: 39 Table of Contents
Completed: Yes Word count: 212285 Read Count: 153181
[Report This] Published: 25 Jun 2012 Updated: 29 Oct 2012
Reviewer: Muddy Signed
Date: 29 Aug 2012 Title: Chapter 20: Chapter 20

I have been reading this story and absolutely loving it over all other stories lately, its been exciting and well written, but I now feel fed up with it because I have come to the realisation from this bar scene that Edward really is just a typical bloke that thinks with his knob! I was under the mistaken impression that he really was feeling something that he had never felt before for Bella, but I think its his dick thinking as his reaction to that Blonde was a real eye opener. He really seemed more interested in being with her and spilling his woes to her but grudgingly trudges up the stairs to Bella then only reacting to her again because she is naked in the bed. Its just a sex thing for him, whereas for Bella I think she really has fallen for him and is going to be hurt badly, just like Rose said. Shame I was hoping this was going to have a HEA ending :(

Reviewer: Muddy Signed
Date: 19 Sep 2012 Title: Chapter 26: Chapter 26

OMG! He better not cheat, that will be the nail in the coffin for me with this Edward, he needs to start sorting his head out and fast where his real feelings for Bella are concerned and man up and fix it, forget Jane!

Reviewer: Muddy Signed
Date: 12 Sep 2012 Title: Chapter 24: Chapter 24

Oh man, I seriously want to bang their heads together now! I am a Cambridge England Woman, born and bred - love that my home town is in this story and yep gotta get the pronunciation right :)

Reviewer: Muddy Signed
Date: 16 Sep 2012 Title: Chapter 25: Chapter 25

I am starting to think this Edward is quite evil, this behaviour is emotionally abusive towards Bella! I was hoping for a HEA but at the moment, I think she should go back to London and forget about him and get her divorce when she's 21 and come back with a serisouly hot (was it Italian in earlier chapter?) man in tow who she then marries and has babies with and a HEA, Edward deserves to have his face rubbed in it with that after the way he has used her for sex basically and messed her up so badly when he should have been caring for her, I think the moment he had sex with her for the first time he crossed a huge line and should have stuck with that and had a 'proper marriage' like they said they would have, not go back on it the minute he got what he wanted from her.

Reviewer: Muddy Signed
Date: 21 Sep 2012 Title: Chapter 27: Chapter 27

Sounds to me that he's still contemplating having some sort of personal thing go on with Jane, probably to try to get him over Bella (never works) and kissing is still cheating. I just want to hug Bella after what he has put her through, that said I am fairly frustrated with them both tho I must admit. He is so selfish that he had to assault James to make himself feel better cos what good will that do Bella? S'pose maybe it might protect other girls from him?Thanks for updating so regularly, I am addicted to this one!

Reviewer: Muddy Signed
Date: 23 Sep 2012 Title: Chapter 28: Chapter 28

I'm curious to see how the heck in the coming chapters Edward is going to redeem himself sufficiently in Bella's eyes, to get a HEA with her!!??! I want to tell her to go get herself some in Italy and forget about that knob but the way they render each other almost pathetic at times it will never happen.Its so good I can't wait for more, but I am so frustrated at them both after every chapter that I want to stop reading it! You are good :)

Reviewer: Muddy Signed
Date: 24 Oct 2012 Title: Chapter 37: Chapter 37

I have loved this story! Its been so good all the way through. Can't wait for the last chapter but don't want it to end! Love that Cambridge was in your story too, its my hometown and was born here. Varsity is nice, been there for a wedding reception. Will we get a glimpse into their future in an epilogue?



Author's Response:

Thanks for your kind words, and I'm so glad you've enjoyed the story.  There will be a little more Cambridge schmexin' in chapter 38, and then the epilogue will take us six months into the future... and then that will be it!!

Thanks so much for reviewing.

Liz

Reviewer: Muddy Signed
Date: 30 Oct 2012 Title: Chapter 39: Chapter 39

Loved it all!! Excellent story from start to finish :-)

Summary:

Banner for You Belong to Me

 

Edward and Bella have a toxic relationship. A tragic accident tears them apart. Can they find a way through their pain to be the couple they are destined to become?


Categories: Canon Pairings, Twilight
Characters: Bella/Edward
Genre: Angst, Drama
Language: English
TWCS Romance Contest: None
Series: None
Chapters: 38 Table of Contents
Completed: Yes Word count: 166245 Read Count: 16240
[Report This] Published: 02 Jul 2012 Updated: 27 Aug 2012
Reviewer: Muddy Signed
Date: 29 Aug 2012 Title: Chapter 1: Chapter 1

I have just discovered this story in the last few days although was sceptical with how disturbing the behaviour between Edward and Bella is in the beginning  I am now addicted. It's a really good story. I hope more give it a chance and read it, its totally worth sticking with!

The One Who Got Away by Racheli Rated: NC-17 starstarstarstarstar [Reviews - 12]
Summary:

Bella met Edward just before their senior year and fell madly in love. But when life after high school pulls them apart, can Bella move on and find love again? Or will she always be in love with the one who got away? AH


Categories: Canon Pairings, Twilight
Characters: Bella/Edward
Genre: Angst, Drama, Romance
Language: English
TWCS Romance Contest: None
Series: None
Chapters: 39 Table of Contents
Completed: Yes Word count: 159385 Read Count: 16798
[Report This] Published: 26 Aug 2012 Updated: 24 Sep 2012
Reviewer: Muddy Signed
Date: 12 Sep 2012 Title: Chapter 1: Chapter 1

I started this story yesterday and have devoured it, its amazing!! I can't wait to see how this ends, please update it soon!!

Summary:

An image of the Seattle skyline with a ferry boat, the Space Needle, and Mount Rainier in the viewEdward runs his family's tour company, which offers one-day itineraries around the Puget Sound. Bella is a tour guide. What sites will these two explore? This is a sweet and light fic about an E/B romance that blooms fast and deep. The rating is for a reason, even if the build-up seems tame. Now complete.


Categories: Canon Pairings, Twilight, All Human
Characters: Bella/Edward
Genre: Romance
Language: English
TWCS Romance Contest: Pure Romance
Series: None
Chapters: 101 Table of Contents
Completed: Yes Word count: 103243 Read Count: 48792
[Report This] Published: 05 Sep 2012 Updated: 17 Oct 2012
Reviewer: Muddy Signed
Date: 06 Oct 2012 Title: Chapter 89: Chapter 89

Great story! I look forward to the updates, so keep going :)



Author's Response:

Thank you!

Summary: Past Featured Story

br

Twenty-two-year-old Bella Swan works for Edward Cullen, the thirty-nine-year-old Vice President at Providence Medical Center in Portland.  After years of fighting their attraction to each other, a quick tryst in the break room leads to a thrilling but complicated relationship.  Trying not to get caught by the prying eyes of their entire workplace, they’re forced to hide their relationship and deal with his ex-wife and his sixteen-year-old daughter.


Categories: Canon Pairings, Twilight, All Human
Characters: Bella/Edward
Genre: Drama, Romance
Language: English
TWCS Romance Contest: None
Series: Stories I've Already read, Lilyellacullens want to read list!, Dumbi's Most Wanted, Stories I've read, My favs past present and future
Chapters: 36 Table of Contents
Completed: Yes Word count: 190983 Read Count: 94873
[Report This] Published: 21 May 2013 Updated: 18 Jun 2013
Reviewer: Muddy Signed
Date: 21 Oct 2012 Title: Chapter 1: Chapter 1 - Providence Medical Center

Just found this and totally addicted already! It's so hot!!



Author's Response:

Aww, thanks!  Glad you're enjoying it.  Thanks for reviewing it.  I really appreciate it,

Summary: Past Featured Story

beyond

The job market is bad, and recent college grad Bella's dreams of being a teacher are crumbling away. Edward is a single father and doctor, struggling to raise his seven year old daughter by himself. Fate intervenes, changing them both forever. Drabble fic. Alternating POV's.

bts

fs


Categories: Twilight, Canon Pairings
Characters: Bella/Edward
Genre: Erotica, Friendship, Romance
Language: English
TWCS Romance Contest: None
Series: To Read (Geddy), Lady Luciole's Favorites TwiHu, Lilyellacullens want to read list!, To Read , luv2write finished reads
Chapters: 40 Table of Contents
Completed: Yes Word count: 22851 Read Count: 161044
[Report This] Published: 02 Dec 2012 Updated: 16 Dec 2012
Reviewer: Muddy Signed
Date: 06 Dec 2012 Title: Chapter 20: Chapter 20

reading few of your stories at the mo, they are great esp this one. I just wish they would be a bit quicker about acting on their feelings! I'm impatient! lol :)