Reviews by songster51
Summary: Past Featured Story

Photobucket

When the disarmingly handsome Edward Masen turns up as a new patient, the life Dr. Isabella Swan has carefully put together will be shattered forever. What will it take to put the pieces back together again? What does it take to heal?

Many thanks to fuzzyltlwingedthing for the new banner!

 

fs


Categories: Twilight, Canon Pairings, All Human
Characters: Bella/Edward
Genre: None
Language: None
TWCS Romance Contest: None
Series: Love to drive's Stories to read, Ageise02 To Read 2, Amberina's Completed Favs List, J's Read and Loved Stories, mamih's favorites
Chapters: 38 Table of Contents
Completed: Yes Word count: 334239 Read Count: 64023
[Report This] Published: 27 May 2010 Updated: 07 Feb 2011
Reviewer: songster51 Signed
Date: 27 Nov 2010 Title: Chapter 1: Chapter 1

I am always excited when I find a new worthy fic amongst the drivel when fic diving.  This looks quite interesting. I do hope Edward is not going to be dying (I suck at angst). I am already reading two fics with an Edward recovering from cancer and they are making me nervous. When I think testicular cancer I automatically think of Lance Armstrong. No matter what people may think of him personally, he has certainly highlighted both the struggle and the impact of the will on recovery. I will continue reading now.

Reviewer: songster51 Signed
Date: 01 Dec 2010 Title: Chapter 4: Chapter 4

I am sorry to be an erratic reviewer. I am normally not but I read on my phone at work. I know, it's a complete waste of taxpayer's money.  If only I cared. Anyway, I hate using a teeny tiny keyboard to write more than a text. Ok, there's my excuse, now to the actual review. I am enjoying this so much. I was rolling when Edward's diagnosis was revealed. That was sort of amazing paybacks for all the douchey Edward types out there.  Seriously, amidst the funny though, I felt glad for him. He's so locked down in every way, kind of waiting for the ax to fall.  First, his mother, then his father checks out and then he dies, then his own body fails him. He's just going through the motions, scared to reach out for happiness because it will hurt worse when it gets snatched away. To find out that his worst fear had not been realized must have felt like an incredible weight had been lifted off.

Diamond in the Rough by lmlx8 Rated: NC-17 starstarstarstarstar [Reviews - 4248]
Summary: Past Featured Story

ditr                   

Bella is coming from a bad marriage, and memories that haunt her. After recieving her Master's degree in Psychology, she begins to embrace her submissive nature. When she mets Edward she is drawn to his Dominating character. Can Edward help her to get over the pain from her past, and find peace at his feet.

 

stories/186/images/th_NDVH_thumbnailsm.jpg

          stories/186/images/banner.png

                                                                                                                                        

stories/186/images/DIAMONDINTHEROUGHBestLemon-300x237.png    stories/186/images/DIAMONDINTHEROUGHBestJacob-300x237.png   


Categories: Canon Pairings, Twilight, All Human
Characters: Bella/Edward
Genre: Action, Drama, Humor, Romance
Language: English
TWCS Romance Contest: None
Series: Domward's Dungeon, I Whitlock's read , My Favorite Stories, Fav BDSM Fics
Chapters: 110 Table of Contents
Completed: No Word count: 949046 Read Count: 1255161
[Report This] Published: 19 Jul 2010 Updated: 18 Sep 2014
Reviewer: songster51 Signed
Date: 02 Nov 2010 Title: Chapter 11: Chapter 11

Hi, there.  I find myself curiously drawn to these stories even when sometimes they squick me out a bit. I apologize for not having reviewed before now, but I just read these chapters pretty much straight through, and when I'm captivated, I find it quite difficult to stop and come up with a thoughtful review. I feel for Bella and her horribly abusive experience.  The fact that she is even willing to consider this kind of a relationship speaks volumes about the strength of her need.  It was probably one reason she was attracted to the asshole James to start with. Edward seems like a responsible guy and he certainly is making it his business to learn everything about her to avoid possible pitfalls.  That's good thinking since she is an abuse victim and is likely to still have PTSD triggers.

I do have a question.  I noticed that at one point you said you had a beta. Would you like to add a second.  I am a beta for several authors and have 10 years of part-time copy editing experience.  I learned to do this from my uncle who owned a string of small weekly newspapers in the Midwest.  I learned to do it before we had all these nice software programs to help---you had to actually know the words and if you didn't, well, you looked it up in a dictionary.  I know, unimaginable now. However, I'm the person who will catch what Spellcheck does not. You know, those words that are words but not used in the correct context; i.e., they're, there, their, lose, loose etc.

I am not trying to be a p.i.a. but you have quite a few typos; i.e., gitty should be giddy, it's Dominant not Dominate.  I would love to help you.  Let me know if you're interested.  I would be happy to go back from the beginning and correct all of the earlier chapters. You've got quite a nice fic going here and I would like to see it be the best it can be.  I beta for Emmanuelle Nathan, Rhian0000, Spring Hale, have done work for Fantasy Mother (one shot for Twilight Gift exchange) and HMonster4 (Last half of Vow of Strongest Stone and all of Swear Not by the Moon), all over on FF if you want to see examples of my work.  Let me know.  In any case I will keep reading.  :-) You can reach me via email edevos51 (at) gmail (dot) com - not sure if this site obliterates URL links like fan fiction but just replace the words with the symbols.

 

Betsy aka songster or songster51

 

Reviewer: songster51 Signed
Date: 02 Nov 2010 Title: Chapter 12: Chapter 12

I'm guessing pain play was on the limits lists and B isn't afraid of it.  I worry that something could trigger a bad response.  Since she still has these nightmares, it wasn't the scene necessarily, maybe just a strange environment.  Being in a strange place is unsettling and sometimes your psyche rebels.  He is taking good care of her.



Author's Response:

As her triggers will prove to come out in later  chapters ....thanks for reading ...lml

Reviewer: songster51 Signed
Date: 02 Nov 2010 Title: Chapter 13: Chapter 13

Whoah. These two will be the death of each other. I guess they will die happy!



Author's Response:

and satisfied ...lol

Reviewer: songster51 Signed
Date: 03 Nov 2010 Title: Chapter 14: Chapter 14

I thought you set a nice even tone.  Not too mushy or over too cold. I'm still trying to understand the whole submission thing. I can understand from time to time giving up control someone else, but the ritualistic nature of their interactions worry me.  I can't help but feel it does sort of objectify women (most subs are women).  I understand that isn't the intent, it just comes across that way.  It's not your writing; it's the tone and the whole Master thing.



Author's Response:

Objectify women? hmmm.. I guess I can see that point of view. However you have to realize that it is the sub who holds all the power. She (it could be a he, but I will use she) gives him the power to control her for their mutal pleasure and benfit...she can also take it away with a signal word. She tells him what she wiull allow and will not and he needs to work within those peramitors...Now he will push her to test those boundries, but he will never step over them....thanks for reading ...lml